The Pizza Casbah

Nothing Tops authentic - hand tossed - stone baked - New York Style Pizza

View Menu

Bringing that New York style to Fort Collins since 1999

Fort Collins' Authentic New York City Style Pizzeria

order online button
catering icon
look at restaurant menu button

Welcome to Pizza Casbah

Locally-owned and operated for over 22 years, we at Pizza Casbah take pride in serving the finest pizza to the Fort Collins community. All of our food is made fresh and prepped daily. Our hand-stretched dough is made from scratch and hand-tossed with a New York-style flair. All pies are stone-baked and topped with our homemade sauces, hand-prepped vegetables, meats, and the highest quality cheeses. We’ve also got gluten-free options available!

But that’s not all! We have jumbo chicken wings delivered fresh, not frozen, a wide selection of freshly prepared sauces, gyros with our house Tzatziki sauce, mouth-watering sub sandwiches, desserts, local brews, and much more! At Pizza Casbah, we guarantee to satisfy all your taste buds! We hope to provide you with a New York experience without the “saucy” NY attitude!

happy hour icon

Happy Hour 4-6pm

$3 Odell and New Belgium Drafts

gluten free icon

Gluten Free Options Available